So, in yesterday’s blog entry, I offered up a short but sweet summary of my rise from humble animation freelancer to landing a gig on the biggest television production in Canada.  I had uprooted, wife and dog in tow, and joined my writing partner, Paul, on a west coast adventure that – at the time, was planned to run two years, culminating in a no-doubt fantastic fifth and final season that would then see us all go our separate ways.  Of course, whether Paul and I would be around to witness that fifth season was up in the air.  Our first season deal was a composed of two parts: the first, a ten episode guarantee that came with co-producer titles; the second, an option to pick us up for the fourth season’s back twelve episodes (remember the days of the 22 episode season?) and a bump up to producer titles.  And so, Paul and I settled in and got to work.

I remember spending a lot of time in our offices that first season, writing.  There was talk of a past writer who had spent much of their time hanging around set in an attempt to ingratiate themselves to the actors, neglecting their script work much to Brad and Robert’s chagrin – and I vowed I would not be that guy. Every day Paul and I would gather in an office (either his or mine) and write.  Back in those days, we were a true writing team.  We would bounce dialogue back and forth between us, essentially giving life to the scene by acting it out in the room.  One of us would pace, the other would write it all down, then we’d switch.  At day’s end we’d head home and, whoever happened to have the updated version of our latest script (usually the last one writing) would spent the evening going over the scenes.  The next day, we’d read what we had and pick up where we left off.  In retrospect, it’s a wonder we were able to get anything done at all using this collaborative method – yet we managed to write 7 of season four’s 22 episode run.

That’s not to say we didn’t spend time on set.  Occasionally, we’d swing by to say hi to the cast and crew, especially when our episodes were being shot, but, for the most part, we tried to stay out of everybody’s hair and get those scripts written.  On any other show, we probably should have spent more time on set to ensure things ran smoothly but, we quickly learned, after three years, the Stargate production was a well-oiled machine.  Executive Producer Michael Greenburg was our dedicated onset producer and we could take comfort in the knowledge that he would put out any potential fires.  Also providing back-up were Co-Executive Producer N. John Smith and Unit Manager John G. Lenic who made sure the ship ran smoothly.

I remember the first big dinner we went to soon after our arrival.  All of the producers gathered for a meal at what was then one of Vancouver’s top restaurants.  John Smith, who has been in the business so long I’m actually more surprised if he DOESN’T know someone, chatted away with the affable owner.  It was a magnificent meal.  The following week, I drove by and was shocked to find the place shuttered.  I had been planning a return visit but, clearly, enjoying another meal there would be out of the question.  What happened?  Well, eventually I learned that the restaurant owner had a little tax disagreement with the government.  You can probably guess who won.  For years, the other producers wondered what had happened to the affable owner and then, some time later (I think it was SG-1’s sixth season) ,Michael Greenburg told us he’d seen him working in a mall sandwich shop.  The story amazed and horrified, branding itself into the back of my mind as a cautionary tale.  The lesson: Work hard, save your money, and PAY YOUR TAXES!

And, in SG-1’s fourth season, I did just that.  I spent my days in the office writing then returned home where I spent much of my free time writing.  As any writer will tell you, ours is not a 9 to 5 job.  It’s not like we can simply switch off our brains in mid-script.  Even if we’re not sitting behind our computer or pacing the corridors of the production offices running dialogue with our writing partners, we’re writing.  Sometimes in the shower.  Often in bed. Occasionally, during dinner when your wife is talking to you.  It can be a lonely business.  For all involved.

I also found time to reach out to the fans, hitting some of the forums in a desire to interact with our audience.  It was a lot of fun and very enlightening, then, eventually, baffling, hurtful, and irritating.  But always entertaining.  Most of those I met online were very nice.  A few, not so much.  And, as that fourth season of SG-1 developed, I was introduced to the wild and wacky world of fandom wars!  But I’ll save the discussion on that topic for a later entry.

Anyway, like I said – we worked hard that fourth season, completing seven scripts.  AND also finding the time to come up with lyrics for the SG-1 opening theme – which we sang, at Peter Deluise’s behest – during the recording of our season four commentary:

Looking back on SG-1’s fourth season:


I remember sitting in Brad’s office when we first came to Vancouver and having Brad ask Robert how he planned to conclude the season three finale, Nemesis.  Well, Rob knew exactly where he wanted to go with the story and broke it down for us.  I remember thinking “There is no way they’re going to be able to pull this off.”.  And yet, he did.  WE did.  Again and again.  The high point of this episode isn’t the Rick Moranis lookalike taking a face full of acid in the teaser, or the Russian dialogue that, when translated, reads: “What’s that noise” “Maybe it’s that bug from the last episode.”, but the outtakes  – specifically, one depicting a seated Thor requesting a Mokochino and another with the Asgard reaching up to goose Carter and getting his face slapped as a result.  This was also the first episode I saw Director Martin (“AND CUUUUUUUT!”) Wood in action and he was a sight to behold.



I remember coming away from this episode impressed by Brad and Robert’s willingness to take chances, especially with regard to our characters.  O’Neill kills someone at episode’s end – and I’m not talking in the heat of battle.  He gives the order to close the iris and then, seconds later, the Eurondan leader apparently steps through and ends up pasted on the other side.  Granted, Jack did warn him not to follow but still – it was a calculated move on the part of the usually happy-go-lucky team leader.  Actor Rene Auberjonois, who played the doomed leader Alar, was a pleasure to work with.  Soon after wrapping production on the episode, he swung by Brad’s office to tell him Alar had a twin brother who’d be more than happy to make an appearance in a future episode. Two other things stand out for me about this episode.  The first was being on set and discovering how they pulled off the chamber-rattling off-screen concussive bursts of the bombings.  Director Peter DeLuise would yell: “Boom!  Shake-shake-shake!”  The actors would feign being rocked while members of the crew would rain dust and sand down on them, unseen overhead.  The second aspect of this episode that will forever stand out for me were those crazy alien glasses that are SO alien that they’re completely counter-intuitive.  In fact, I believe Rick made a gag of it in the episode by going to take a sip, giving the glass a curious look, then turning it around and drinking from the backside.  This was Peter DeLuise at his best and his desire for alien props (from rounded hammers to red spray-painted kiwis) would be a source of endless amusement for Paul and I.


This was the episode that introduced me to the realities of the scriptwriting process.  The fact is, as a show’s Executive Producer, it’s your job to make sure the episode is as good as it can be.  As a result, you’ll be asked to cast the best actors, choose the best costumes and props, approve the best visual effects, sign off on the best cut and, most important of all, see to it that the script is as good as it can be.  Often, this involves providing a writer with detailed notes for a rewrite.  Occasionally (but a hell of a lot more than you, dear viewers, will ever know), it involves doing a pass on a script not your own – anything from a dialogue polish to a full script rewrite.  But even in cases where a script is thoroughly rewritten, the original writer will retain sole credit.  And so, more times than I can count, I’ve perused the boards and had to bite my tongue (or cross my typing fingers) as I read posts lauding Writer X, knowing full well that while Writer X’s name may have been the credited writer, the person who should’ve been lauded was Brad or Robert or Paul.  I remember Paul sitting in our offices at one point in our Stargate run, amused because he had two scripts nominated for an award: one, on which he’d been co-credited on that I actually wrote, the other on which he’d received no credit but which he’d actually written.  It’s a strange, strange business.  Anyway, in the case of Upgrades, it was simply a case of a script that was tonally very different from first draft to shooting script.  The original version had actually been very serious but, after Robert Cooper did his pass, it was transformed into a hilarious entry and one of my very favorites.  The highlights of this episode for me was the memorable saran wrap force field (augmented with visual effects, but saran wrap nevertheless – I loved watching the dailies of our hero getting their face smooshed as they ran into the damn thing).


In the original version of this script, Teal’c exacts his revenge on Tanith and the episode concludes with, if not exactly a happy ending, then sure a satisfying one.  But Brad suggested that, instead, we end the episode with Teal’c restraining himself and Tanith getting away with Shau’nac’s murder – at least temporarily.  “That’s pretty dark,”I recall Paul saying.  “I like dark,”countered Brad.  And so did I.  The original version of the script also contained a reference to the fact that Teal’c had gotten a (Jaffa) divorce from his wife, freeing him up to pursue that amorous rendezvous with his long lost love.  Unfortunately, for some reason, it didn’t make the final draft and, as a result, Teal’c ended up looking like a big slut to many fans.  All that being said, the high point of this episode for me was that damn pointy Tok’ra digs, everything from the porcupine walls to the lethal high-backed chairs.  It’s a wonder they weren’t impaling themselves all the time.


Some point to this episode as the genesis of the grand shipper vs. anti-shipper debate as O’Neill and Carter finally admit their feelings for one another – and I suppose it was, except it didn’t come as much of a surprise.  Shippers rejoiced as, after after three years of unspoken mutual attraction, “Sam and Jack” became canon.  Anti-shippers, on the other hand, were less than enthused.  And the forums lit up!  And it wasn’t just the ship they were referring to.  It was also the death of their beloved Martouf and the continuing presence of the Anise character, introduced in response to then President of MGM Television’s Hank Cohen’s request for “a sexy female alien” (A suggestion he got to repeat onscreen when he played himself in Wormhole Extreme).

In my next entry, I’ll tackle a few more episodes (including our version of Groundhog Day), the hiring of Ivon Bartok, and “the ship” sails on (at least in the early drafts of Beneath the Surface it did).

45 thoughts on “April 23, 2011: Days of Stargate Past – SG-1 Season Four!

  1. I love the lyrics to the Stargate theme song. I can remember listening to that commentary and hearing it. It was perfect. Season 4 was pretty damn good.

  2. Don’t suppose there is any more film of the Saran wrap takes?? You could win $$ on America’s Funniest Home Videos!!

    See I read this and I read your reaction to the fans and I wonder if there is something wrong with me. I never ever thought Tel’c was a slut I knew he was married but I don’t know. I have tunnel vision when I watch shows I love. I feel the writers, producers, actors and all involve can do no wrong. I can’t wait to read what you mean with Fan Wars…. This interesting to me. I don’t go on many fan forums because of my very low tolerance for ignorance. As a job as a manager I deal with stupid people on a daily basis and it’s not in my nature to be confrontational and I don’t enjoy using words to hurt people. So I’m curious to see how you took people’s negative words, did it motivate you? Anger you?

    I was SAD to see the character of Martouf go but such is life the people we care most die and it brought more of a connection from audience to Carter!! But again that’s just my opinion!

    Thanks again, to be honest these have been some of my favioute

  3. Joe last entry not done!! Damn auto correct was trying to hit the little “x” on iPad and it posted comment. Please add th following and delete this comment.

    “favourite posts that you have written, can’t wait to read more!!”

    Thanks Joe sorry if I make/made more work for you!!

  4. So, Joey…when you’re writing in the shower, is Paul in there with you, too?? 😉


  5. I gotta say, Joe, that I love these entries. They’re bringing back some great memories of “discovering” SG-1 and doing our own little marathons to catch up to current eps.

    These that you wrote for season four were some really fun ones.

    And I’m SO glad you included a link to your song lyrics, especially since my wife and I wrote (and would sing) lyrics to the End Title music after every episode

    Just follow along the main melody of the End Title and sing it with us! (you have to lead the third line with the “We” so that you hit “love” on the first note of that line)

    We all love to go through the Stargate
    Every voyage seems to tempt the fates
    We love to go and gate to other worlds
    And in the process take out some Goa’ulds
    We killed Apophis AND his Jaffas
    We all love to go through the Stargate
    We all think that it is really great

    (love that End Title melody!)

  6. And he sings too!! Is there anything you can’t do?
    LOVE this blog theme! What Sg1efc said. Really cool.

  7. Ah yes, the Tanith story. The first case (that I can think of) of our good guys basically screwing over a total innocent. Tanith’s host, I mean, who thought he was doing a good, helpful thing by becoming a host. Then when it turned out it was really a gould at first they’re all like, we’ll totally save him. And then when Tanith killed someone one of our heroes cared about, they’re like, screw it, vengeance is more important than trying to rescue an innocent. Teal’c’s possible skankiness aside, *that’s* the thing that annoyed me about that storyline. That and the really weird way that it wrapped up in the teaser of a completely unrelated episode.

    If I was on a writing team and a network exec asked us to add a ‘sexy female alien’, I’d probably have a hard time restraining myself from banging my head on the desk right then and there. I mean, really.

  8. @Shawna: I agree.

    These are such great memories Joe. With as many episodes and many memories you have of them, this will fill your blog until 2012. It’s been awhile since I’ve watched SG-1 from episode 1 season 1 all the way through (I have the 10-season boxed set). I had forgotten about that little gem (the song).

    Any special Easter plans for tomorrow? I’m working (and not complaining by the way; just a statement of fact). Tomorrow is just a weird trifecta day. There is Easter, there is my aunt’s wedding anniversary and it’s the anniversary of my dad’s death (21 years). No sadness in that, just an acknowledgment of the day. Just hard to believe 21 years have passed.

    Patrick’s previous public school is going to visit his current placement on Monday. I still don’t know what their agenda is–if they are doing this to have a period of free discovery (to see if there is actually something to worry about if I were to file due process, which I still can do before August of this year) or if they just want to get rid of me because they know the damaging things I have on them. Can’t imagine it’s because they want to do the right thing, but I guess it is within the realm of small probabilities. The only reason why I’m letting them do this is because they have offered to help “maintain” the placement. I don’t know if that means pay the whole tuition or a portion of it. Trust me, it better be all of it because their re-involvement into our lives is not worth just a portion of it. I hope he will be feeling okay that day, that he won’t freak out by seeing them. Keep good thoughts for him that day everyone please.

  9. Thank you so much for taking the time to revisit SG1 and Atlantis, especially since you must be crazy busy with Transformers.

    I loved so many episodes, it’s hard to pick just a few. But what was equally fun to watch were your behind the scenes videos. I really loved Harmony, and it would be great to see your on set visit again.

    Is it possible in the future for you (or someone else) to organize them by show as a sidebar on your blog?

    Hope you have a Happy Easter with Akemi and the pups! And a Happy Easter to everyone here as well.

  10. Don’t forget it was also Carter’s suddenly sexy, non-Air Force hairdo and moon eyes, and Daniel’s sudden marginalization, that got fandom going.

    Actually, I don’t think I can stand to relive the years of fan vs TPTB, fan vs fan, and TPTB + fan vs fan struggles. It’s only been 10 years and the wounds are still raw. 🙂 See you in Season 7!

  11. Oh yeah! That scene with Teal’c and Tanith and how intense T is, doing all he can to restrain himself from choaking the life out of Tanith. And Tanith just pushing the perverbial knife in deeper and deeper. And everytime I see Peter Wingfield in a show, that’s the scene that comes to mind…Tanith, you SOB!!! Great writing. I’m glad it was changed so Teal’c could get his revenge later.

  12. Yes sir, may I have another… episode. I love that you are going episode by episode.



  13. Coucou!!

    ça va bien Joseph? Je vous souhaites une JOYEUSE PÂQUES!!!!!!…ne mangez pas trop de chocolat 😉

    Que des bons épisodes! Mes amis pensent que la saison 4 et l’une des meilleurs de sg1 moi je prefère les saisons 8,9 et 10 =D!

    Passez une bonne journée!
    Gros bisous!!!

  14. Ah Joe! So enjoying your SG memories, thank you for sharing them with us.

    I was lucky enough to see Martin (AND CUUUUUT!) Wood in action last year – he’s still a sight to behold! 🙂



  15. Why did you quit with Vanessa Angel?

    I’ve heard she didn’t get along with you guys that well but I have no idea if that’s true. Her outfits sucked, but then, most of the Tok’ra outfits sucked. Surely that could have been fixed. I remember thinking she would have been handy to have in a few episodes when you needed a “scientist” type.

  16. Excellent entry.
    I didn’t know for the Russian translation in Small Victories:
    “What’s that noise?”
    “Maybe it’s that bug from the last episode.”
    That is SO funny!

  17. love to hear news.. old news i know but still 🙂
    I dint think, like Penny, that teal’c was a slut nor did i think that he was cheating on his wife. Ive always thought that they were more like friends than actual lovers.
    and i was wondering. in what episode do the asgaard kill themselves? I simply cant find it.
    is it stupid to hope for an ending of sgu?

  18. It’s so much fun reading this. It brings back so many memories of the time I watched these episodes =D

    Thank you again, for sharing!

    It’s funny, because I really like the other side just because it is so dark.
    Stargate always had more the touch of reality than most other shows. I can’t name one that came even close, especially in it’s genre.
    It’s also the biggest reason for making it my favorite out of the three 😉
    Guess that’s taste right there!

  19. On another note, I was rewatching some stargate atlantis episodes and why did you kill off carson beckett, he was my second favorite character, and then you only brought him back for 5 episodes in the last season, you should have made him a main character again.

    Was there a role planned for him in the 6th seaason?

  20. Joe,

    These entries are awesome! Thank you so much for sharing your stories with us all.

    Have a great day,

  21. Joe, thank you for sharing your memories of Stargate with us. Back in the early days I used to catch a couple of episodes in syndication (I don’t have any extra pay channels) until the 7th season hiatus when I discovered all the past season episodes running on Sci-fi on Mon and a different set airing every week night. I was probably almost caught up when the back half of seasin 7 started up and I have loved Stargate ever since, although in its 2nd season Atlantis became my favorite.

  22. Book. You have to write a book. I don’t care if it’s just taking these blog entries. ,maybe throwing in a few fillers, and publishing, or if you use the entries as bonus material. But You really really need to think about putting out a book on the SG experience. Maybe a collaborative effort with some of the other show makers? And a bonus dvd with some of the outtakes and behind the scenes videos? I’m loving every bit of these posts. All we fans owe you one serious debt of gratitude, and maybe some chocolate.

  23. Ever since I started reading your blog, one of my favorite things has been when you have gone behind the scenes. Enjoyed reading the Season Four memories and am looking forward to today’s entry.

    For those who celebrate Easter, I hope you are having a wonderful holiday.

  24. Joe, a question for the mailbag if you accept:
    Where can we see the concept art of the exterior appearance of Destiny Ship ?

    Thank you. ^^

  25. J’adore lire ces retours dans le passé, c’est très informatif et ça me permet de voir l’émission sous un nouvel angle. Merci!

    Oh, et “Futura est le nom d’un Font…” hahahaha!!

  26. Speaking of pointy things…hehe….that was one interesting costume compared to the other Tok’ra costumes.

    I’ll raise my hand as a Sam and Jack shipper. I do love reading the people that positively deny that there was ever anything in the scripts or performances to demonstrate it. They’re so amusing.

    I’m loving all of this BTS of the writing process..I was trying to figure out who the writer that hung around set was and starting looking at the writing credits of the first few seasons…I got distracted – I didn’t know Hart Hanson wrote for SG1 – you learn something new every day.

    Cheers, Chev

  27. Here I go again… @ Thornyrose YES! Oh what a great idea Joe, take these blog entries of reminisces and add in some other thoughts from fellow writers, producers, crew and cast and WRITE a BOOK!

    I anticipate a great many (millions) of readers and interested Stargate fans would gladly snatch it up! A Joe & company POV of the behind the scenes antics, trials and tribulations of the Stargate phenomena! Huzzah!

    And, lest I forget, blessings to all on this holy Easter Sunday.

    (enjoying a glorious, 74’F in my part of NJ)

  28. Hey Joe

    Did you get outside and enjoy our wonderful Southern Ontario weather yesterday?


  29. Okay, now I’m curious. Do you have any video of Martin (“AND CUUUUUUUT!”) Wood in action? Can you show what you mean. I love Martin Wood!

    And I also agree with everyone who has suggested it (2cats, Thornyrose, Tammy Dixon, and others) write a book! Behind the Scenes: The Making of Stargate. With lots of pictures. And it comes with a DVD in the book sleeve. I think it would be a HUGE seller.

  30. Sorry for the late response, been somewhat busy.

    So you liked Eden of the East Joe? That’s cool, a lot of people seem to think it’s based in the same universe as Ghost in the Shell stand alone complex, like a prequal or something.

    I had a feeling you’d like the show which is mostly why I said to check it out, seemed something by your taste in anime you’d like.

    Such a shame no one has even thought to do an Eden of the East live action series, it’d be so easy to do it’s not even funny. Hardly any special effects would be needed, just a decent lead male to play Takizawa and a female to play Saki, and a mixed cast to play the Seleção, it’s one show that would rely on having a quality cast more than anything.

    Hope someone does it someday.

  31. I miss SG1 Joe, you more than anyone seem to understand what people want from a Stargate series, I would like to hope that any future Stargate show is helmed by you, RCC, Paul, Carl and everyone else involved with the past Stargate shows, okay so SGU wasn’t successful, no reason why you all shouldn’t be given another chance.

    Because why would MGM want new producers for a potential new show when they already have several popular, well liked producers that respond well to the fans?

  32. I finally watched Game of Thrones because I had a free HBO weekend on DirecTV last weekend. It was incredible. Reminded me of the series “Rome” but with a LOTR twist. Jason Momoa didn’t have a large speaking role (not yet at least), but he owned the screen when he was on it.

    The only bad part? No more free HBO. Now I’ll have to wait to see the rest of it.

  33. Work hard, save your money, and PAY YOUR TAXES!

    that should be a bumper sticker.

    ah, anise.
    in upgrades her outfit wasn’t too bad, except for that thing around her neck.

    which got dropped later in the episode;

    it’s better in crossroads;

    but in devide and conquer, it’s borderline absurd;

    (your picture is better) and you can see why christopher judge called her 12 of 15 (or whatever) in reference to 7 of 9 from star trek: voyager.
    loved the scene where she tells jack that she wants him, but her symbiont wants daniel.

    looking forward to more reminiscing.

  34. This makes me want to break out the DVDs yet again. There are so many great episodes in season four. Love hearing your take on what happened, etc. Keep it coming.

  35. Wait, YOU killed Martouf?!

    I may have to rethink this reading-Joe’s-blog-everyday thing.


  36. Thanks for the YouTube clip of you guys singing. My cats were not impressed and ran out of the room as I was listening, but at least they didn’t howl. 🙂

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.